43 replies to this topic

[_Crusader6_]

If I where you, I would break them down by class - and rate them that way.

  Most players have preferred play styles that allow them to do better in one class over another.

 

 

[Motorbreath_]

The real question is Wargaming's doctrine on autoloaders; they will not let an autloader's total damage based off of alpha damage exceed the tank with the highest single shot damage in the tier (which is usually held by tank destroyers)

In the case of the T57 Heavy and AMX 50 B, they are restricted by the 183. But this poses an interesting question; for tier X autoloaders, does the 183 have to be the deciding factor every time? 

 

For the Foch 155, if they gave it a Defender-style autoloader, it could be possible:

155mm Gun

2 shells

5.2 second inter-clip reload

22 second full reload

4.1 second aim time

0.352 dispersion

640/545/800 (AP/HEAT/HE)  <------------------ |

280/370/75 (AP pen/HEAT pen/HE pen) <----- You can't have two 960 damage HE shells that can pen 90mm of armor

 

[SanguinaryDan]

theFANTASTICfox, on 14 April 2018 - 11:10 AM, said:

The real question is Wargaming's doctrine on autoloaders; they will not let an autloader's total damage based off of alpha damage exceed the tank with the highest single shot damage in the tier (which is usually held by tank destroyers)

In the case of the T57 Heavy and AMX 50 B, they are restricted by the 183. But this poses an interesting question; for tier X autoloaders, does the 183 have to be the deciding factor every time? 

 

For the Foch 155, if they gave it a Defender-style autoloader, it could be possible:

155mm Gun

2 shells

5.2 second inter-clip reload

22 second full reload

4.1 second aim time

0.352 dispersion

640/545/800 (AP/HEAT/HE)  <------------------ |

280/370/75 (AP pen/HEAT pen/HE pen) <----- You can't have two 960 damage HE shells that can pen 90mm of armor

 

NO!  Don’t you touch the Foch!  I love it the way it is. If WG gave it an auto loader they would nerf the living hell out of it in some other, horribly ill thought out, way. For God’s sake man, if it ain’t broke don’t “fix” it.  And the Foch 155 works quite well as it sits. 

[therealrattler]

theFANTASTICfox, on 14 April 2018 - 04:10 PM, said:

The real question is Wargaming's doctrine on autoloaders; they will not let an autloader's total damage based off of alpha damage exceed the tank with the highest single shot damage in the tier (which is usually held by tank destroyers)

In the case of the T57 Heavy and AMX 50 B, they are restricted by the 183. But this poses an interesting question; for tier X autoloaders, does the 183 have to be the deciding factor every time? 

 

For the Foch 155, if they gave it a Defender-style autoloader, it could be possible:

155mm Gun

2 shells

5.2 second inter-clip reload

22 second full reload

4.1 second aim time

0.352 dispersion

640/545/800 (AP/HEAT/HE)  <------------------ |

280/370/75 (AP pen/HEAT pen/HE pen) <----- You can't have two 960 damage HE shells that can pen 90mm of armor

 

Wait a second- doesn't the defender have 1200 clip potential. That breaks the rule, right?